Wednesday, December 9, 2009
Night Bookers Book Club's Discussion of Summer by Edith Wharton
The Night Booker's had an interesting discussion about the book Summer by Edith Wharton. Many thought the main character, Charity, was self absorbed. One member said she never would have spoken to her parents the way Charity spoke to her "foster" parent Mr. Royall. Others thought Charity acted tough because she came from the Mountain. (Mr. Royall took her from the Mountain when she was five years old). She felt people looked down on her because she came from the mountain, so she compensated by being tough. The members did find it creepy that Mr. Royall wanted to marry Charity after she had lived in his house since she was a child. However, the group felt he redeemed himself at the end. When Charity's love affair with Harney is over and she is left pregnant, Mr. Royall marries her. One person said it was a win/win situation for everybody. Mr. Royall got Charity. Charity got someone to take care of her and her child, but will always have the memories of her love of Harney. Some people thought Harney was the villain. Others thought if Charity had never met Harney, she never would have grown as a person. The book was written at the turn of the century, which made it different. There was not a lot of dialogue with the characters. The reader must assume what happened. One person loved the scene where Charity stood outside Harney's window and just watched him. That scene would not have been written today. And the other love scenes between Harney and Charity were very subtle. The group ended with someone suggesting we watch the movie Summer! This might be a possibility.
Labels:
Book Club,
Edith Wharton,
Night bookers Book Club,
Summer
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)